The moment quotes arrive, most buyers do the human thing: sort by price and start with the cheapest. The problem is that three quotes are usually three different answers to three slightly different questions. Until the questions are aligned, you’re not comparing prices. You’re comparing assumptions.
Send the same sheet to everyone
One document: dimensions, materials, hardware brands, finish, colour, packing requirement, order quantity, target port. No mood boards, no “something like the photo, you know”. If each supplier guesses the gaps differently, each quote is right for a different product — and you’re not comparing anymore.
This is also the first honest test of a supplier. The ones who ask real questions back — which foam density, which hinge, what carton thickness — are telling you they read the sheet. The ones who quote instantly on a four-line email are telling you something too.
Line up the basis
Same trade term (EXW, FOB or DDP — next note covers these). Same currency. Same validity — most quotes hold for 15 to 30 days, because material prices move. A quote from six weeks ago is not a quote.
Read what’s excluded
The price rarely lies. It just stays quiet. Left out most often: upgraded packing, branded hardware, tooling or mould fees for custom sizes, and freight validity. Two quotes can differ by 8% and buy exactly the same product once you add back what one of them quietly dropped.
Treat the outlier as information
When one quote lands far below the others, it almost never means inefficiency or generosity. It means a different spec somewhere: thinner board, lighter hardware, smaller internal dimensions, weaker packing. Furniture is a category where one photo can hide five different products. Ask the cheap quote to itemize, and watch the gap close by itself.
Then compare people, not just numbers
By the time the numbers are aligned, you’ll also know who answered fast and completely, who corrected your mistakes, who pushed back where it mattered. On a first order, that information is worth as much as the spread between the quotes. The cheapest aligned quote from a supplier who went silent twice is not the cheapest.
Next note: the three letters that decide who carries what — EXW, FOB and DDP, in plain language.